A doctor hires an escort to seduce her husband, whom she suspects of cheating, though unforeseen events put the family in danger.
23 Feb Chloe (2009)
The Son
Thinking about film and how it works is made easier when you have two films that in some way are similar.
Here we had an original French film that was really quite effective. It powerfully gave us the inner dance of two conflicting souls of the performance of Woman. It was delicate, took fewer risks than we would allow, but impressed by its structure and intent.
Now it is transferred to the English language, a transition that usually and unnecessarily dulls the edges. The filmmaker is Atom Egoyan, who has made at least one essential film. I should say ‘director‘ rather than filmmaker because this has none of his precise confusion, none of his danger. He clearly is a director for hire, with someone else having commissioned a compete rewrite.
We still have two women and a husband. We still have fragments of the situation. But the whole thing is restructured. We no longer have an inner exploration, puzzlement, self- negotiation. We no longer explore humanness. Now it is all external. These really are two competing women in a traditional thriller model. Instead of allowing the structural drift into internal issues, we now have a son who plays an essential role, establishing an external observer.
This is a mess. The writer previously did well in being and writing a tortured woman. For some reason, the producers thought that was what ‘Nathalie‘ needed. Gosh, what a bad calculation! And that’s with Julianne Moore, who could have made the original into life- altering art.
Posted in 2011
Ted’s Evaluation — 1 of 3: You can find something better to do with this part of your life.
No Comments